Buying or selling discounted gift cards: how the resale market works
How discounted gift cards work: why cards sell below face value, which brands keep their value, the risks for buyers and sellers, and the checks that matter.
In this article 11 sections
You can buy gift cards below face value from resale marketplaces such as CardCash and GCX, or new from warehouse clubs such as Costco and Sam’s Club. You can sell an unwanted card to a resale marketplace, but always for less than its balance. The difference between those two prices is the market: sellers trade some value for cash today, buyers get a discount for taking a card someone else didn’t want, and the marketplace keeps a cut for checking the cards and standing behind them.
This guide explains how that works, which cards hold their value, what can go wrong on each side, and the checks that protect you. GiftCards.now doesn’t buy, sell or trade cards, and we have no affiliate or partner agreement with the companies named here. We list them because they are widely used, not because we tested them, and what follows is what each company says about itself, checked in November 2026. This is general information, not financial or legal advice.
Why do gift cards sell for less than face value?
Because a gift card can only be spent at one store, and cash can be spent anywhere. Someone holding a card they won’t use will accept less than the balance to turn it into money, and a buyer will only take a card someone else didn’t want at a discount. The resale company sits in between and keeps part of the gap.
On a buy-and-resell exchange like CardCash, the company buys your card outright (it says it pays up to 92% of card value2) and resells it at a smaller discount. On a marketplace like GCX, sellers set their own price4 and GCX takes a 15% commission6 when a card sells. Either way, a seller gets less than a buyer pays, and the difference covers the company’s fraud checks, guarantees and profit.
A hypothetical example of the spread: if an exchange pays a seller $85 for a $100 card and sells it to a buyer for $92, the seller gives up $15, the buyer saves $8, and the exchange keeps $7, out of which it must cover any card that turns out to be stolen or empty.
Which gift cards keep their value best?
Cards for stores people shop at every week. Demand for them is steady, so sellers get more and buyers save less. Cards for niche stores, movie theaters and casual dining are wanted by fewer people, so they trade at bigger discounts.
CardCash’s home page on November 12, 2026 showed the spread clearly. These are the top discounts it listed for buyers, as published that day1:
| Brand | Listed discount (up to) | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|
| Walmart | 1% | Almost as good as cash |
| Starbucks | 4.6% | High, steady demand |
| Barnes & Noble | 5.5% | Steady demand |
| Macy’s (online only) | 6.5% | Some restrictions on use |
| Carnival Cruises | 7% | Large, planned purchases |
| Domino’s | 8.6% | Plenty of supply |
| Olive Garden | 9.4% | Plenty of supply |
| Dunkin’ | 10.6% | Plenty of supply |
| Ross | 12.8% | Fewer buyers |
| Cinemark | 14% | Occasional use |
| Buffalo Wild Wings | 16.1% | Fewer buyers |
| Regal Cinemas | 20.9% | Occasional use |
The right-hand column is our reading, not CardCash’s. For a seller, the same logic runs in reverse: a Walmart card will fetch a better offer than a Regal card of the same balance. For a buyer, the big discounts are on brands you have to be sure you will use. Restaurant cards are also what warehouse clubs discount most: Costco describes its restaurant cards as typically 20% to 25% off9, and Sam’s Club lists cards at up to 25% savings10.
The two kinds of resale company
Buy-and-resell exchange (CardCash)
- You get a firm quote before you send the card.
- Paid quickly: CardCash says payment usually goes out 1 to 2 days after approval.
- Pay by check, ACH or PayPal, or trade for another brand’s card.
- Buyers get a 45-day guarantee against balance problems.
Peer marketplace (GCX)
- You set the price, so you can ask for more.
- Paid only when a buyer purchases your card; new sellers have 14-day payout terms.
- 15% commission and a $0.30 listing fee for new sellers.
- Buyers get a 90-day guarantee, but pay a buyer protection fee on discounted cards.
Sources: CardCash FAQ2, GCX seller tiers7, GCX guarantee5, GCX buyer protection fee8. Our reviews of CardCash and GCX go deeper, and CardCash vs Raise and Raise vs GCX explain how Raise’s old marketplace became GCX.
What happens when you sell a card, step by step
On an exchange, you search for the store, enter the balance and get an offer. CardCash’s FAQ2 says many cards can then be submitted online by typing in the card number and PIN, while others must be mailed, with free USPS shipping for physical cards. It checks the balance, approves the order, and pays, typically within 1 to 2 days of approval, or 24 to 48 hours after a mailed card arrives. New customers may be asked for extra information before the first payment.
On a marketplace, you create a listing with the balance and your asking price. GCX checks the card, publishes the listing, and waits for a buyer. Its seller tier table7 sets the rules for new sellers: listings expire after 90 days, a single card can’t be worth more than $500, and payout terms are 14 days. If nobody buys at your price, the listing simply sits until it expires. The longer it sits, the more you risk the store changing its terms or closing before it sells.
On the buying side, the order runs in reverse: you pay, the card number and PIN appear in your account or a physical card is mailed, and the guarantee clock starts on the purchase date, not the day you first try to use the card. That is why checking the balance on day one matters more than anything else on this page.
Is it safe to buy a discounted gift card?
From an established marketplace with a written guarantee, mostly yes, as long as you use the card soon. The real risks are a card whose balance was spent or stolen before you got it, and a store that closes before you use it. From strangers online, no: the FTC warns that cards on online auction sites may be fake or stolen11.
The main risks for buyers, and what limits them:
- A drained or short card. Covered for 45 days at CardCash and 90 days at GCX, if you report it in time. After that, the loss is yours, so check the balance the day the card arrives.
- A card the original owner still controls. If a seller registered the card in a store app, they may still be able to spend it. GCX excludes cards that buyers merge into merchant apps against its terms, so read the rules before you do.
- The store goes out of business. The CFPB notes a store card may not be redeemable13 if the retailer goes under, and GCX’s guarantee doesn’t cover that case. Don’t stockpile discounted cards for months.
- Restrictions. Some cards are online-only or regional. Read the listing.
- A buyer fee. GCX’s buyer protection fee is charged as a share of your savings, from 10% on small discounts to 25% on the biggest, so a listed discount isn’t the whole picture.
What are the risks of selling a gift card?
Mostly getting less than you expected, or getting nothing because you sold to a scammer. Established exchanges verify sellers and pay on a stated schedule; strangers online who want the card number and PIN first are how sellers lose cards.
- Low offers. "Up to 92%" is a ceiling. Get a quote for your exact card and compare it with what a marketplace would pay after its commission.
- Payment delays. A marketplace only pays when your card sells. GCX lists 14-day payout terms for new sellers, and an account that sits untouched for 12 months is charged a $5 monthly dormancy fee, so withdraw your money.
- Reversals. GCX charges new sellers a $5 refund fee if a buyer’s refund is debited from them. If your card had less on it than you listed, expect to pay it back.
- Verification you can’t meet. CardCash requires a real credit card, not a debit card, to verify sellers, and won’t take expired cards or promotional cards restricted to certain locations or products.
- Fake buyers. Never send the card number, PIN or a photo of the back to someone who hasn’t paid you. The FTC says the card number and PIN let someone take the money11 even if you still hold the card.
If your card is nearly empty, you may not need to sell at all: some states make stores pay out small balances in cash. See gift card expiration, fees and cash back.
Fraud checks before you buy or sell
- Use a company that is still operating. Cardpool shut down in February 202114 and ClipKard’s site showed a "Store Closed" notice15 from August 2024. Old lists still link to both.
- Read the guarantee: how many days, and what it covers. A dead card or wrong balance usually; a change of mind, never.
- Check the balance yourself on the issuer’s own site or phone number. See how to check a balance.
- Pay with a credit card where you can, so you have a dispute route if the seller won’t fix a problem.
- Keep a photo of the card front and back and the receipt, as the FTC advises, in case you need to file a claim or a report.
- Never deal with someone who contacted you first offering to buy or sell cards, or who wants payment in crypto or by wire.
What federal law says about the card you are buying
US gift cards are covered by the CARD Act of 2009, put into effect by the CFPB’s Regulation E, 12 CFR 1005.2012. It applies to the card, not to who owns it, so a resold card has the same protections as a new one.
- A store gift card can’t be sold with funds that expire in less than five years, as the CFPB summarizes it13.
- A dormancy, inactivity or service fee is allowed only after a year12 with no activity on the card, only if the card discloses it, and no more than one such fee in a calendar month.
- Reloadable prepaid cards that aren’t sold as gift cards aren’t covered13 by these rules.
Some states go further. If you think a fee or expiration date on a card breaks the rules, you can complain to the CFPB or your state attorney general17.
Can you sell or buy gift cards at a kiosk?
Not any more. Coinstar machines count coins and pay out cash, eGift cards or donations; its help center16 lists no way to sell a gift card. The yellow gift card exchange kiosks that used to stand next to them have shut down. Coinstar can still turn coins into an eGift card, and its help center says most US locations offer eGift options with a 0% fee. See our Coinstar review and CardCash vs Coinstar.
Where to buy and sell
We keep two up-to-date roundups: the best places to buy discounted gift cards (warehouse clubs, CardCash, GCX, the Raise app, promo codes and fuel-point weeks) and the best places to sell gift cards (CardCash, GCX, trades and private sales, and what has closed). If you just want rid of a card, our guide to unwanted gift cards covers swapping, regifting and donating too.
Should you buy or sell discounted gift cards?
Buy when the brand is one you will spend at within weeks, the discount survives any buyer fee, and the seller has a written guarantee. Sell when you are sure you won’t use the card, after checking whether the store will give you cash for a small balance, and only to an established exchange or someone you know. In both cases, check the balance yourself and keep a photo of the card. For a CardCash trade, compare the offer with the cash price: its sell page3 says trades can pay up to 8% more.
Sources
- CardCash: Home page discounts (Nov 12, 2026) cardcash.com
- CardCash: FAQs cardcash.com
- CardCash: Sell gift cards cardcash.com
- GCX: Sell gift cards gcx.app
- GCX: 90 Day Money-Back Guarantee gcx.app
- GCX Help: Seller fees help.raise.com
- GCX Help: Seller Tiers help.raise.com
- GCX Help: Buyer Protection Fee help.raise.com
- Costco: Restaurant gift cards costco.com
- Sam’s Club: Up to 25% savings gift cards samsclub.com
- FTC: Avoiding and reporting gift card scams consumer.ftc.gov
- CFPB: 12 CFR 1005.20, requirements for gift cards consumerfinance.gov
- CFPB: Giving or receiving gift cards? Know the terms consumerfinance.gov
- Doctor of Credit: Cardpool shuts down permanently (Feb 2021) doctorofcredit.com
- Internet Archive: ClipKard “Store Closed” page (Aug 7, 2024) web.archive.org
- Coinstar: Help Center coinstar.com
- NAAG: Find my AG naag.org
Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@giftcards.now.