English

CardCash vs Coinstar (2026): selling gift cards vs cashing in coins

CardCash vs Coinstar: Coinstar no longer buys gift cards, but turns coins into fee-free eGift cards. CardCash buys unwanted cards. Fees, payouts, which to use.

Green plant in clear glass vase
Photo by micheile henderson on Unsplash
In this article 12 sections

Short answer: if you want to sell a gift card, use CardCash, not Coinstar. Coinstar kiosks no longer take gift cards; today they turn coins into cash vouchers, eGift cards or charity donations. If you have a jar of coins, Coinstar’s eGift card option is the way to cash them in with no fee at most US kiosks, as long as you want a card from one of its partner brands. Paper cash from Coinstar costs a fee of up to 15.9% plus up to $0.99.

People search “CardCash vs Coinstar” because Coinstar once ran kiosks that bought gift cards for cash. That service is not part of what Coinstar offers now. Below: what happened, what each company does in 2026, the fees and payouts, and which to use for what. We read both companies’ pages on November 12, 2026. Fees and offers change, so always check the screen or the quote before you commit. This is general information, not financial advice.

Does Coinstar buy gift cards?

No. Coinstar’s own help center describes kiosks that count coins and pay out a cash voucher, an eGift card or a charity donation, and it says “We are also not able to exchange an eGift Card for cash.” There is no gift-card-for-cash service on the Coinstar pages we read.

It used to be different. In a March 2015 post, Travel with Grant4 described “a Coinstar Exchange kiosk where you can convert gift cards to cash in a few minutes,” a tall yellow machine separate from the green coin counters. His three test cards paid about 63% of face value: $27.04 for a Panera card with $42.92 on it, $15.75 for a $25 Chipotle card and $31.50 for a $50 Elephant Bar card. A reader comment on that post dated October 31, 2024 says Coinstar no longer offers a gift card exchange for cash.

Coinstar’s help center1 today covers coins, cash vouchers, eGift cards and donations, and its gift card page2 is only about buying eGift cards with coins. If you still find an article or a map listing a “Coinstar Exchange,” it is out of date; check Coinstar’s own kiosk locator before you drive anywhere with a gift card. Wikipedia3 still mentions “Coinstar Exchange for gift cards” in passing, without dates; Coinstar’s own pages are the better guide to what kiosks do now.

What does Coinstar do now?

Coinstar counts loose coins at kiosks in stores and gives you a cash voucher to redeem at the store, an eGift card from a partner brand, or a donation to charity. The eGift card is the no-fee option at most US locations; cash carries a service fee.

From the Coinstar help center1:

  • Cash: “a service fee of up to 15.9% of the transaction amount plus a transaction fee of up to $0.99.” You get a paper voucher, which Coinstar says to redeem “at the store in which it was issued” and “on the same day it was issued.”
  • eGift cards: “Most locations in the United States offer eGift Card options with a 0% fee,” though “eGift Card fees vary by retailer, brand, and location.”
  • Charity: Coinstar keeps “a 10% processing fee” on donations to national charities and a 7.5% fee for regional charities.
  • Limits: no foreign, commemorative or pure silver coins, and “If you think that you have more than $3,000 in coins, we may be able to provide special assistance.”
Coinstar’s fee by payout option (US, as stated by Coinstar)
  • Cash voucher (maximum)up to 15.9% + up to $0.99
  • National charity10%
  • Regional charity7.5%
  • eGift card (most US locations)0%

Read November 12, 2026. Fees vary by location and brand; the kiosk shows the fee before you confirm. Source: Coinstar help center

Is there a fee to get an eGift card from Coinstar?

At most US kiosks, no: Coinstar says most US locations offer eGift cards “with a 0% fee,” and its gift card page says “Fees start at 0%!” But fees vary by brand and location, and not every brand is at every kiosk, so check the screen before you pour.

Coinstar’s gift card page2 listed 20 brands when we checked: AMC, Apple, Applebee’s, Cabela’s, Chili’s, Domino’s, DoorDash, GameStop, Gap Options, Hotels.com, IHOP, Lowe’s, Nike, Outback Steakhouse, Roblox, Red Robin, Southwest Airlines, Starbucks, Texas Roadhouse and The Home Depot. It adds that “Not all eGift Cards are available on every kiosk.” Notice what is not on the list: no Amazon and no Visa or Mastercard. The eGift card is free, but it locks your money into one brand.

The arithmetic is simple. A hypothetical $80 of coins at a 15.9% cash fee plus $0.99 would leave $66.29 in cash. The same $80 as a 0% eGift card for a store you shop at anyway is worth the full $80 there. If you would not otherwise spend $80 at any brand on the kiosk, the free card is not really free; it is $80 you now have to spend at one store.

Can you sell a Coinstar eGift card to CardCash?

Possibly, but check the brand’s terms first: several Coinstar partner brands ban resale. Coinstar’s gift card page quotes Home Depot saying its cards “cannot be resold, exchanged or transferred for value” and GameStop saying its cards may not be “resold.”

The same Coinstar page2 notes that Domino’s prohibits resale through unauthorized channels, and that Red Robin, Hotels.com, Applebee’s and Gap Options cards cannot be used to buy other gift cards. So the trick of turning coins into a free eGift card and then selling it for cash is a bad plan twice over: you lose the resale discount, and you may break the card’s terms. Choose a brand you will spend.

Brown round coins on brown wooden surface
Photo by Dan Dennis on Unsplash

How does CardCash buy gift cards?

Online: you enter the brand and balance, get a quote, submit the card and get paid. CardCash advertises “up to 92%” of face value and says most sellers are paid within 1 to 2 business days by check, ACH, PayPal or an instant virtual Mastercard.

That is from CardCash’s sell page6 (“Get Quote, Submit Cards, Get Paid”) and its “Is CardCash legit?” page5, which also says the company has operated since 2009, is owned by Giftify, Inc. (NASDAQ: GIFT) and has processed more than $1 billion in gift cards. The 92% is a best case; restaurant and niche brands usually get less. You can also trade a card for another brand instead of cash, which CardCash says can sometimes be worth more.

A hypothetical: a $100 card at an 80% offer pays $80, paid to your bank, PayPal or a virtual Mastercard. Compare that with Coinstar, which will not take the card at all.

Does Walmart have a gift card exchange with CardCash?

It did, as a test. In December 2014 Walmart launched a CardCash-run site where shoppers swapped cards from more than 200 brands for a Walmart eGift card. We could not find that exchange running in 2026: its walmart.cardcash.com address did not resolve when we checked.

Money8 reported on December 24, 2014 that shoppers entered card details at Walmart.CardCash.com and got a Walmart gift card by email, with an Amazon card fetching 95% of its value and other brands less, and that “Walmart says this exchange is a test but could be made permanent if there is heavy demand.” CardCash still shows a Walmart logo among the partners on its legit page5, without details. We could not confirm that any Walmart exchange runs today, so do not count on one.

Can you exchange gift cards in a store?

Coinstar kiosks no longer do it. CardCash’s newest in-store deal is with Follett: in June 2026 it announced gift card exchange at about 700 Follett campus bookstores, to be rolled out by August 2026.

The June 29, 2026 release9 says the program “enables students, parents, and campus visitors to exchange unused gift cards for spendable value” at participating campus stores, naming Stanford University and the University of Texas among the schools served. It does not say exactly what form that value takes. Outside a campus store, selling online is the reliable route.

Using a Coinstar kiosk for a fee-free eGift card

  1. Find a kiosk. Coinstar’s help center1 says to “enter your zip code or city and we’ll show you the stores that have a Coinstar kiosk.” Brand choice varies by kiosk, so if you have a particular brand in mind, have a backup.
  2. Sort out what it will not take. Foreign coins, commemorative coins, pure silver, Eisenhower silver dollars and 1943 steel pennies are all rejected, per the help center.
  3. Choose the eGift card and read the fee on screen before you confirm. Most US kiosks show 0% for eGift cards, but fees vary by brand and location.
  4. Keep the printout safe. The eGift card comes as a paper voucher with “a unique code printed at the top.” Coinstar cannot cancel, reissue, exchange or cash it out, so photograph it and use or load it into the brand’s app soon.

If you choose cash instead, the same help center says to redeem the voucher at the store where it printed, on the same day.

Selling a gift card to CardCash: what to have ready

  1. The exact balance. Check it on the brand’s site or the receipt (see how to check a gift card balance). A wrong balance can get a sale reversed.
  2. The card number and PIN, entered only on cardcash.com itself, never sent to someone who messaged you offering to buy it.
  3. A payout method in your own name: bank account, PayPal or an address for a check. CardCash runs fraud screening on sellers, so expect it may ask you to confirm who you are on a first sale.
  4. A comparison. Before accepting, compare the offer with a marketplace such as GCX, which can pay more on popular brands if you are willing to wait for a buyer.

CardCash vs Coinstar at a glance

CardCashCoinstar
Buys gift cards?Yes, online, “up to 92%”No
What you put inA gift card (number and PIN)Loose coins
What you getCheck, ACH, PayPal, virtual Mastercard, or another brand’s cardCash voucher, eGift card, or charity donation
FeeBuilt into the offerCash: up to 15.9% + up to $0.99; eGift: 0% at most US kiosks
Speed“Most sellers get paid within 1–2 business days” (company claim)Voucher prints on the spot
Also sells discounted cards?Yes, “up to 35%” offSells eGift cards at face value for coins

Sources: CardCash5, CardCash buy page7, Coinstar help center1, read November 12, 2026.

Don’t pay anyone with a Coinstar eGift card

A printed eGift code is as good as cash to a scammer, and Coinstar cannot cancel it. If someone on the phone tells you to turn coins or cash into gift cards and read them the codes, hang up. The FTC10 is blunt: “No real business or government agency will ever tell you to buy a gift card to pay them.” If it already happened, contact the brand that issued the card right away, keep the voucher and receipt, and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. More in our gift card scams guide.

On the legal side, eGift cards you get from Coinstar are ordinary store gift cards, so the CFPB’s gift card rule (12 CFR 1005.20)11 applies: funds cannot expire within five years of issue, and an inactivity fee is allowed only after a year without use, at most once a month. Some partner cards go further: Coinstar’s page quotes Texas Roadhouse’s as “No fees. No Expiration.” See gift card expiration, fees and cash back.

Which should you pick?

CardCash fits if

  • You have a gift card you will never use and want money for it.
  • You want the payout in your bank, in PayPal or on a virtual Mastercard.
  • You would rather swap the card for a brand you do use.

Coinstar fits if

  • You have coins and will happily spend the total at one of its partner brands (0% at most US kiosks).
  • You need cash today and accept the fee of up to 15.9% plus up to $0.99.
  • You want to donate coins to charity in one step.

Unwanted gift card: CardCash, or compare with other buyers in best places to sell gift cards and what to do with unwanted gift cards. Coinstar cannot help.

Jar of coins: Coinstar’s eGift card if there is a brand on the kiosk you will spend at; otherwise weigh the cash fee against other ways to deposit coins.

Want a discounted card instead: CardCash sells cards below face value too; compare it with GCX in CardCash vs Raise.

Read our CardCash review and Coinstar review for the details. We don’t buy or sell cards ourselves, and this is general information, not financial advice.

Sources

  1. Coinstar help center coinstar.com
  2. Coinstar: eGift cards coinstar.com
  3. Wikipedia: Coinstar en.wikipedia.org
  4. Travel with Grant: Coinstar Exchange gift card test (Mar 2015) travelwithgrant.boardingarea.com
  5. CardCash: Is CardCash legit? cardcash.com
  6. CardCash: sell gift cards cardcash.com
  7. CardCash: buy gift cards cardcash.com
  8. Money: Walmart will trade you for other merchants’ gift cards (Dec 2014) money.com
  9. Giftify’s CardCash launches campus gift card exchange with Follett (June 29, 2026) barchart.com
  10. FTC: Avoiding and reporting gift card scams consumer.ftc.gov
  11. CFPB: Regulation E § 1005.20, gift cards consumerfinance.gov

Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@giftcards.now.

Compare every platform side by side

More guides