English

Compare / CardCash

CardCash review

Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on GiftCards.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate

Good for

  • Selling or trading an unwanted card fast, at a fixed offer you see up front, and buying restaurant or movie cards at a modest discount.

Skip it if

  • You want the highest possible price for a popular card and don’t mind waiting for a buyer, or you buy cards to keep for months: the buyer guarantee lasts only 45 days.
Visit CardCash

CardCash calls itself the web’s first secondhand gift card market. It was co-founded in 2009 in New Jersey, built a Walmart-branded trade-in site that Walmart called a test in late 2014, and since the start of 2024 has belonged to Giftify, Inc., the Nasdaq-listed parent of Restaurant.com. Unlike a marketplace, CardCash buys your card itself at a price it quotes, then resells it. That makes selling simple: you enter the brand and balance, see an offer, and accept it or walk away.

How much you get depends on the brand. Its FAQ says it pays "up 92% of the card value" and that you won’t know your number until you ask for an offer. Payment comes by check, ACH deposit or PayPal, "typically sent within 1 - 2 days of order approval", and mailed-in physical cards are paid 24 to 48 hours after they arrive. You can also trade your card for another brand’s, which CardCash calls the "best bang for your buck". As a purely hypothetical example, a $100 card at an 85% offer would pay $85. Expect a $1 authorization on your credit card when selling; CardCash says it drops off within 24 hours.

White paper with green and brown flower
Photo by Annie Spratt on Unsplash

For buyers, discounts are real but mostly small on the brands people use every day. On November 12, 2026 Walmart cards were up to 1% off and Starbucks up to 4.6%, while Dunkin’ was up to 10.6%, Buffalo Wild Wings 16.1% and Regal Cinemas 20.9%. Those numbers move daily. The catch is the guarantee: you must report a bad balance "within 45 days from the date of purchase". Recent BBB complaints come from buyers whose cards went invalid months later, and CardCash pointed to the 45-day limit. Use what you buy quickly, or at least check the balance with the brand right away; our balance guide shows how.

Its record is otherwise clean for this industry. BBB rates it A+ and lists 301 complaints over three years, about half filed as product issues. In a 2015-16 Florida racketeering case, investigators told the Chicago Tribune that storefronts had sold gift cards from stolen goods through Raise, CardCash and others; CardCash itself was not charged. That is the structural risk of any resale site: some cards come from fraud, and the guarantee is your protection.

Verdict: one of the safest places to sell a card for cash when you want certainty and speed, and fine for buying cards you will spend within a few weeks. Compare its offer with a marketplace before you accept, as we do in CardCash vs Raise and the best places to sell gift cards. General information, not financial advice.

The facts

Prices & discounts
Discounts listed on Nov 12, 2026 ran from up to 1% off Walmart cards and 4.6% off Starbucks to 10.6% off Dunkin', 16.1% off Buffalo Wild Wings and 20.9% off Regal Cinemas. Popular big-box brands carry the smallest discounts; restaurants and movie theaters the biggest. Prices change daily with supply.[1]
What it does
Sells discounted secondhand gift cards (digital and physical), buys unwanted cards for cash, and trades them for a card from another brand. Founded in 2009 in New Jersey and owned since 2024 by Giftify, the parent of Restaurant.com; it built a Walmart-branded trade-in site as a 2014 holiday test and launched a Starbucks exchange in 2019. Website and iOS/Android apps.[2][3][4][5]
Buyer protection
Buyers must report a balance problem "within 45 days from the date of purchase". After that window a card that goes bad is your loss, so use or check cards you buy promptly.[2][6]
Selling & payouts
CardCash says it pays "up 92% of the card value"; the real offer depends on the brand. Payment by check, ACH deposit or PayPal, "typically sent within 1 - 2 days of order approval" (mailed-in cards: 24 to 48 hours after they arrive). Trading for another brand's card usually pays more than cash. Sellers get a $1 card authorization that drops off within 24 hours; no seller fees are listed.[2]
Track record
BBB rates CardCash A+ (accredited July 2025) and lists 301 complaints in three years, half filed as product issues; recent ones include buyers whose cards went invalid after the 45-day window, which CardCash declined to refund. In a 2015-16 Florida racketeering case, investigators said storefronts sold stolen-goods gift cards through Raise, CardCash and ABC Gift Cards; CardCash was not charged. We found no FTC, CFPB or state attorney general action against CardCash.[6][7][8]

Sources

  1. CardCash: home page and listed discounts (checked Nov 12, 2026) cardcash.com
  2. CardCash: FAQ (payouts, payment methods, 45-day guarantee) cardcash.com
  3. CardCash: About us and company history cardcash.com
  4. GlobeNewswire: RDE, Inc. (owner of Restaurant.com and CardCash.com) renames itself Giftify, Inc. (Oct 2024) globenewswire.com
  5. TechCrunch: Walmart and CardCash launch a Walmart-branded gift card exchange (Dec 2014) techcrunch.com
  6. BBB: CardCash.com business profile (A+, accredited since July 2025) bbb.org
  7. BBB: CardCash.com complaints (301 in 3 years, checked Nov 2026) bbb.org
  8. Chicago Tribune: Gift card exchange site draws scrutiny as bad cards trip up consumers (Nov 2016) chicagotribune.com

Visit CardCash · Compare all platforms