Compare / Gift Card Granny
Gift Card Granny review
Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on GiftCards.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate
Good for
- Buying a Visa or Mastercard gift card with a photo or logo, or a brand eGift card with a promo code, from a long-running seller with a lifetime guarantee.
Skip it if
- You want to sell a card, or expect deep discounts: its own cards are sold at face value, and the bargains it lists are on partner sites with their own rules.
Gift Card Granny started in 2009 as one of the first gift card price-comparison sites and is now owned by Wolfe, LLC of Pittsburgh, the company whose founder built GiftCards.com and sold it to Blackhawk Network in 2016. Today it does three things, according to its own company description: it sells Visa, Mastercard and brand gift cards directly, it lists discounted cards from partner resellers (you finish the purchase on the partner’s site), and it runs a cash back program.
Its Visa and Mastercard cards carry a one-time processing fee set by value, per its fee schedule: $2.95 up to $74.99, $3.95 up to $149.99, $4.95 up to $249.99, $5.95 up to $349.99 and $6.95 up to $500. Store-brand cards have no fees. So a $100 Visa costs $103.95 before any shipping, a dollar less than the same card at GiftCards.com. On November 12, 2026 a promo code gave 5% off select brands, including Macy’s, Barnes & Noble, Sephora and H&M. Our Visa gift card fee comparison lines up the main sellers.
The guarantee is the strongest here on paper: a "100% Lifetime Guarantee" on the integrity and balance of cards it sells directly, with a replacement or refund. It does not cover cards you buy from partners through its comparison pages, and digital cards can’t be refunded once delivered. Granny Cash Back can be redeemed for eGift cards or a check but expires a year after it is issued. A lost or stolen Visa or Mastercard costs $5 to replace.
Gift Card Granny doesn’t buy cards. Its help center says it "no longer serves as a gift card exchange" or buys cards from individuals. Its BBB file shows an A+ rating and 44 complaints in three years, including an order cancelled after a compliance review without a reason and cards that would not redeem. Its replies cite fraud checks, which every seller of prepaid cards runs; we found no regulator action.
Verdict: a good place to buy a personalised Visa or Mastercard, with slightly lower fees than some rivals and an unusually long guarantee. It is not where you sell, and its discount listings are only as good as the partner you land on. See Gift Card Granny vs CardCash. General information, not financial advice.
The facts
- Prices & discounts
- Visa and Mastercard gift cards ($10 to $500) carry a one-time processing fee of $2.95 to $6.95 by value; store-brand cards have no fees. On Nov 12, 2026 a code gave 5% off select brands (Macy's, Barnes & Noble, Sephora, H&M). Discounted cards from partner sellers are listed for comparison.[1][2]
- What it does
- Sells physical and digital Visa/Mastercard and brand gift cards directly, compares discounted cards from partner resellers (you check out on the partner's site), and runs Granny Cash Back Rewards, redeemable for eGift cards or a check; cash back expires a year after it's issued.[3]
- Buyer protection
- Promises a "100% Lifetime Guarantee" on the integrity and balance of cards it sells directly, with a replacement or refund. It does not cover cards bought from partner sites through its comparison listings, and digital cards are non-refundable once delivered.[3][4]
Sources
- Gift Card Granny: Visa gift card fee schedule giftcardgranny.com
- Gift Card Granny: home page and current promotions (checked Nov 12, 2026) giftcardgranny.com
- Gift Card Granny: company knowledge base (ownership, guarantee, cash back, refunds) giftcardgranny.com
- BBB: Gift Card Granny business profile, Pittsburgh (A+, accredited since 2019) bbb.org
- Gift Card Granny help: Selling Gift Cards (no longer an exchange or buyer of cards) help.giftcardgranny.com
- Gift Card Granny help: How much does it cost to buy a gift card? help.giftcardgranny.com
- BBB: Gift Card Granny complaints (44 in 3 years, checked Nov 2026) bbb.org