English

Compare / Coinstar

Coinstar review

Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on GiftCards.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate

Good for

  • Turning a jar of coins into a gift card for a store you already use, usually with no fee.

Skip it if

  • You want to sell a gift card (Coinstar stopped buying them in 2019), or you need cash: the cash option can cost up to 15.9% plus 99 cents.
Visit Coinstar

If you hoped to sell a gift card at a Coinstar machine, that option is gone: Coinstar’s separate gift card kiosks, called Coinstar Exchange, stopped taking cards on June 26, 2019, as Lifehacker’s updated report notes. Today’s green kiosks only count coins. For an unwanted gift card, see CardCash vs Coinstar and what to do with unwanted gift cards.

What Coinstar does well is the reverse trip, coins into a gift card. Its Help Center says most US locations offer eGift cards "with a 0% fee" from more than 20 stores and restaurants, though fees "vary by retailer, brand, and location", so read the kiosk screen before you pour. Taking cash instead costs a service fee of up to 15.9% plus a transaction fee of up to $0.99. As a hypothetical at those maximum rates, $50 in coins would leave you about $41.06 in cash, or the full $50 on a no-fee eGift card.

A group of coins
Photo by Allison Saeng on Unsplash

Treat the printed slip like cash. Coinstar says it can’t cancel or reissue a lost or stolen eGift voucher, won’t swap one you picked by mistake, and won’t exchange it for cash. Photograph the code before you leave the store. A cash voucher should be redeemed the same day at the store where it printed. Donations are fee-free for you, but Coinstar keeps 10% for national charities and 7.5% for regional ones. If you have more than $3,000 in coins, Coinstar asks you to call customer service first.

The printed codes have caused trouble before. In 2016 Outerwall, Coinstar’s owner at the time, settled a Washington class action alleging that eGift codes printed on thermal paper faded until they couldn’t be used; it denied wrongdoing and agreed to warn customers and recalibrate printers. Coinstar is also shutting its crypto service: kiosk crypto purchases end November 19, 2026 and CINQ wallets close January 4, 2027. Coin counting and gift cards are not affected.

Verdict: a good, usually free way to turn coins into a gift card you will actually spend, and a poor way to get cash. It cannot help with a gift card you want to sell. General information, not financial advice.

The facts

Prices & discounts
Coins to cash costs a service fee of up to 15.9% plus a transaction fee of up to $0.99, varying by location. Coins to an eGift card is free at most US locations, but Coinstar says eGift fees "vary by retailer, brand, and location", so check the kiosk screen before you pour.[1][2]
What it does
Pour in loose coins and choose a cash voucher, an eGift card from 20-plus store and restaurant partners (selection varies by kiosk) or a charity donation. Crypto purchases at kiosks end Nov 19, 2026.[1][2]
Buyer protection
Printed cash and eGift vouchers are treated like cash: Coinstar can't cancel or reissue them if lost or stolen, and it won't swap an eGift card picked by mistake or exchange one for cash. Photograph the code right away.[1]
Selling & payouts
Coinstar stopped buying gift cards when its Coinstar Exchange kiosks ended on June 26, 2019; today's kiosks only count coins.[3][1]
Track record
In 2016 Coinstar's then-owner Outerwall settled a Washington class action alleging that eGift codes printed on thermal paper faded until unusable; it denied wrongdoing and agreed to warn customers and adjust printers. Separately, its CINQ crypto wallets close on Jan 4, 2027.[4][5]

Sources

  1. Coinstar: Help Center (fees, eGift cards, vouchers) coinstar.com
  2. Coinstar: eGift Cards (Coin to Card) coinstar.com
  3. Lifehacker: Coinstar Exchange kiosks (updated: no gift card exchange kiosks since June 26, 2019) lifehacker.com
  4. Top Class Actions: Coinstar gift card class action settlement (Washington, 2016) topclassactions.com
  5. Coinstar: CINQ by Coinstar crypto services being discontinued coinstar.com

Visit Coinstar · Compare all platforms